City Fare Cafe and Catering

483 Main St, Buffalo, NY 14203, United States
+1 716-907-5600
$$$ Cafe
(77 Reviews)
Price Range $10–20

Nestled in the heart of downtown Buffalo, City Fare Cafe and Catering is more than just a cafe—it's a vibrant community hub where food lovers gather to indulge in an array of delectable dishes. With an inviting atmosphere, friendly staff, and a menu that expertly blends creativity with classic flavors, this cafe has quickly become a local favorite.

City Fare is particularly renowned for its fresh and flavorful salads, with highlights including the Onassis Salad, a delightful mix of crisp greens, vibrant toppings, and signature dressings that leave customers raving. For those looking to satisfy a hearty appetite, the Little Nicky sandwich and the hearty Tempeh Of Doom will transport your taste buds to new heights. Customers have commented on how "everything we have eaten is great," and with portions that guarantee you'll leave full (perhaps even with leftovers!), this is a spot you won’t forget.

The cafe's atmosphere is warm and welcoming, making it an ideal place for a casual lunch break or a gathering with friends. Many reviews highlight the truly outstanding service, with patrons like Shannon Kauderer noting the "super quick and attentive" staff who ensure that each visit feels personal and special. Whether you're grabbing a quick bite on the go or enjoying a leisurely meal, you can count on being treated like family here.

City Fare is also a go-to choice for events and catering, promising unforgettable culinary experiences for your special occasions. Past customers, like Dunbar Berdine, raved about how the team catered a wedding flawlessly, turning the day into a stress-free occasion with great food and professional service. Meanwhile, Andrew Gray reflected how the catering menu “pleased everyone and their different tastes,” making it an easy choice for any gathering.

Another standout, the Curry Chicken Soup, has garnered praise for its rich flavor, while fan-favorite desserts, like the scrumptious peanut butter cookies, round out the menu perfectly. From the moment you take your first bite, it's clear that City Fare Cafe and Catering is dedicated to quality and customer satisfaction.

For those looking to experience a true gem in Buffalo, make your way to City Fare Cafe and Catering. Whether you're dropping by for a refreshing salad or planning your next big event, this decentralized cafe offers something for everyone, complete with a team that consistently goes above and beyond to deliver joy through their food.

Accessibility
Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
Has wheelchair-accessible seating
Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
Service options
Offers takeaway
Serves dine-in
Popular for
Popular for lunch
Good for solo dining
Good for working on laptop
Offerings
Serves coffee
Serves comfort food
Serves healthy options
Quick bite
Serves small plates
Serves vegetarian dishes
Dining options
Serves lunch
Has catering
Serves dessert
Has seating
Amenities
Has toilet
Atmosphere
Casual
Cosy
Payments
Accepts credit cards
Openings Hours
Checking

Monday

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Tuesday

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Wednesday

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Thursday

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Friday

11:00 AM - 2:00 PM

Saturday

Closed

Sunday

Closed

77 Reviews
p zelasko

29 Aug 2025

Very very friendly staff. Great food. They didn't have tap to pay as a warning but allowed me to venmo them instead - my fault for not having a card on me.

Dunbar Berdine

03 Aug 2025

City fare did the catering for my daughter’s wedding and it was perfect. The food was great and the staff was friendly and professional. They made the day very easy for us.

Andrew Gray

02 Aug 2025

We used City Fare to cater my father’s birthday party. I was so impressed with the selections we could choose from. The final menu was amazing. The food pleased everyone and their different tastes. I highly recommend City Fare. I will use them again.

Mike Tomasso

31 Jul 2025

Had a great catering experience. Melissa customized the menu to exactly what we wanted. Everyone loved the different sandwiches and salads. We had requests for gluten and dairy allergies, which were handled without a problem. The peanut butter cookies are delicious! Definitely recommend for anyone looking for an easy option for food at parties and get-togethers.

Shannon Kauderer

19 Jul 2025

The curry chicken soup is phenomenal. The little Nicky sandwich was ok, could have been a bit spicier. Amazing service, super quick and attentive.

annabeth Mg

19 Jul 2025

We love this little downtown lunch place! The food is fresh and delicious, everything we have eaten is great!! My kid LOVES their soups. Today we had clam chowder and this homey rich potato cheddar. The salads are crisp and fresh, and the portions: you will leave full with leftovers!! Absolutely worth visiting, and the owners are amazing. So friendly and hard working. Do not miss!

Kristi Weissman

25 Jun 2025

Stopped in looking for a bite to go. I got the Malibu Barbie and it was sooo delicious. Toasted bread, fresh ingredients. Highly recommend. The owners were very friendly and welcoming!

Brendan Doyle

22 Jun 2025

I love this salad. It is called the Onassis and it is completely delicious. Please support this Cafe. All the food is good. Purchased a combo lunch the other day and I could not finish it.So good!!! The potato soup was so filling I hardly had room for the sandwich. Everyone there are so wonderful to deal with.

Join the City Fare Cafe and Catering Newsletter

Get the latest updates on seasonal pastries, special events, and local highlights directly in your inbox.